My experience is primarily in TEM and I know that concentrated
glutaraldehyde tends to polymerize over time and we never let our 3%
glut. exceed 4 months in age. I've learned that formaldehyde gets more
acidic over time, but when is it too far gone?
Douglas W. Cromey, M.S.,
dcromey@ccit.arizona.edu
...................................................................................................................
The same discussion has been going on in our lab with regards to 4%
paraformaldehyde. We have noticed a definite change in as little as one
week after fix preparation, and marked changes after 2 weeks. Our
fixatives are generally kept no longer than 4 weeks. The changes we
notice are that with transcardiac perfusion, the body gets very rigid
within 5 min. when using fix less than 1 week old. It takes longer for
body stifeening after 1 week and athe body remains semi-limp after two
weeks, but the brain histology still looks fine after overnight immersion.
So it might be that there is some diminuition of fixative strength, but
not so much that early postmortem changes are not arrested, and it takes
longer for thourough fixation to occur.
Glen MacDonald
glenmac@u.washington.edu
.........................................................................................................................
Formaldehyde that is prepared from paraformaldehyde powder is normally
made fresh just before use since it very poor shelf life. However, it is a
relatively pure form of formaldehyde and is used usually with glutaraldehyde
as a fixative for EM studies. Commercially available 37% formaldehyde
solution on the other hand has impurities including methanol and therefore
is not good for EM studies. But it can be readily used for studies
at the light microscopy level. It is quite stable compared to the
formaldehyde generated from paraformaldehyde powder. I had the opportunity
a few years ago to compare results obtained from cells fixed with a new and
a 2 year-old stock of the 37% formaldehyde (for the fluorescent-localization
of F-actin with Rhodamine/Phalloidin). I could not detect any difference.
From: "M.V. Parthasarathy"
The changes are detrimental to product quality but may be avoided or kept
at a minimum by maintenance of proper storage conditions. With optimum
conditions of storage, commercial formaldehyde will remain unimpaired for
long periods of time. In general, proper storage involves avoidance of
temperature extremes and the use of storage in glass bottles, inert to
corrosion by the mildly acidic solution. Low temperature favor polymer
precipitation, high temperatures accelerate the reaction leading to
chemical loss of formaldehyde. At improper storage temperatures, a form-
aldehyde solution gradually becomes cloudy and eventually solid hydrated
polymer separates as a precipitate.
as an additional measure to all those already mentioned ;-) for
keeping formaldehyde solutions as long as possible, I seem to
remember that, before those days when we began preparing our
formaldehyde immediately before use, we kept it in bottles with
a lot of calcium carbonate on the bottom. This took acidification
into account, but did not avoid polymerisation, of course ;-)
HTH.
........................................................................................................................
Whenever possible we only make enough fixative for that day. That goes for
glut., paraformaldehyde or glut/para mixes. If we need to store it before use
we keep it frozen. We have not done any longevity test but it seems to be good
at least one month. We usually use it up before any longer time. We do the
same with 8% glut vials that we have opened and not used completely. We seal
the top with parafilm and then place the vial in a screw top jar with a good seal.
Since an aqueous solution of formaldehyde (even made fresh from
paraformaldehyde) exists as an equilibrium between methylene glycol and
formaldehyde (skewed heavily towards the m.g.), covalent linkage of
formaldehyde to tissue molecules is very slow , reaching equilibrium in 16
h @37 C (eg., reviewed in Fox et al. J Histo Cyto 33:845-853, 1985). This
argues that BRIEF fixation in formaldehyde (as in immuocytochemistry preps)
induces artifacts because of the high concentration of methylene glycol,
and that little actual crosslinking occurs. Why use formaldehyde as a
fixative for EM?
R. Howard Berg
internet: bergrh@cc.memphis.edu
......................................................................................................
If you are really interested in reading about fixatives and how they work
there is a chapter devoted to this in the book by G. Griffiths. The ref. is
"Fine Structure Immunocytochemistry" 1993 published by Springer Verlag,
Heidel
Subject: Fixative Quality Control
To members interested in fixatives, formaldehyde solution in particular.
Here are some additional informations about storage of commercial form-
aldehyde.
The principal changes which may take place in formaldehyde on storage are
as follows (listed in their order of importance from a practical standpoint):
(1) Polymerisation and precipitation of polymer.
(2) The Cannizzaro reaction, involving oxidation of one molecule of form-
aldehyde to formic acid and reduction of another to methanol.
(3) Methylal formation.
(4) Oxidation to formic acid.
(5) Condensation to hydroxyaldehydes and sugars.
Much more could be said about this highly interesting fixative which
possesses many unusual characteristics.
--
* Sverker Enestr*,
...................................................................................
From: desclinj@ulb.ac.be (Desclin Jean)
********************************************************
From: DCROMEY@CCIT.ARIZONA.EDU
Subject: More on Formaldehyde QC
Thanks for the many responses to my initial posting Re: Fixative Quality
Control. I've done some more reading, called a few suppliers and
incorporated the responses from the microscopy listserver to create a
memo for the labs I work with. A copy follows for those who are interested:
*************************************************************
We have been doing some research about the shelf life of 37%
Formaldehyde. There is no definitive age after which 37% Formaldehyde is
no longer useful as a stock solution. Formaldehyde chemistry is
moderately complex, but after discussions with other microscopists,
manufacturers and reviewing pertinent texts, the following observations
are applicable. Formaldehyde should be stored at room temperature, cold
temperatures encourage the formation of trioxymethylene with a resulting
white precipitate. Formaldehyde should be stored tightly sealed, since
exposure to air encourages the oxidation of formaldehyde to formic acid
(37% formaldehyde is usually shipped with 10-15% methanol to inhibit this
change). Our recommendation is, if the 37% formaldehyde solution is
clear, colorless and has no precipitate, and has been stored at room
temperature in a tightly sealed bottle that has not been exposed to
sunlight, it should be good, however, we still do not recommend using a
stock bottle that is older than 1 year, bottles that are already opened
should not be used more than 6 months. Consequently, we recommend that
labs purchase their formaldehyde more frequently and in smaller
quantities than perhaps they have done in the past.
*************************************************************
There's more, but this should suffice. The only additional comment is
that 37% formaldehyde is not recommended for EM work and that a higher
grade "methanol-free" formaldehyde or a solution made from
paraformaldehyde should be used instead.
Thanks for your help:-{)
Douglas W. Cromey, M.S.
dcromey@ccit.arizona.edu
........................................................................................................
From: "W.L. Steffens"
One fixative that really works much better than it should is McDowall-
Trumps, which is a modified Karnovsky-type fix. It is prepared from bulk
(reagent grade) glut and commercial formalin in a phosphate buffer. Its
popular in clinical laboratories where much of the tissue received is
pathological or from necropsy. People around here like it because its
cheap (a couple of dollars per gallon) and is stable for months.
I personally like fixatives that incorporate picric acid, for its ability
to retain proteins. Picric acid is not a fixative per se, but acts by
precipitating proteins, rendering them insoluble. We routinely use 2% GTA-
2% formaldehyde-0.5% picric acid in cacodylate buffer. It produces good
contrast in just about everything vertebrate. This "yellow" fix is stable
for at least 2 months.